Design Thinking Exercises Compared: Which Activity Works Best for Each Phase

Choosing the right design thinking exercise determines whether a workshop produces actionable ideas or a wall of forgotten sticky notes. The table below rates 18 of the most widely used design thinking activities across six criteria — phase, time required, ideal group size, difficulty level, remote-friendliness, and best use case — so facilitators can match the right exercise to their team’s experience level, format, and objectives.

At IDEO we have dedicated rooms for brainstorming sessions, and the rules are literally written on the walls: Defer judgment. Encourage wild ideas. Stay focused on the topic. The most important of them, I would argue, is ‘Build on the ideas of others.’

Tim Brown, Change by Design

How to Read This Comparison

Each exercise is rated on a consistent scale:

  • Difficulty — 1 = no prior design thinking experience needed, 5 = requires experienced facilitator and participants familiar with the methodology.
  • Remote-friendly — Yes = works fully in digital tools (Miro, FigJam), Partial = works but loses some effectiveness vs. in-person, No = requires physical materials and in-person interaction.
  • Time — Minimum recommended duration. Add 5–10 minutes for instruction and debrief if the team is new to the exercise.
  • Group size — Optimal range. Larger groups should split into sub-teams of this size.
Five phase design thinking timeline

The Full Comparison: 18 Exercises Rated

This is the core of the page. Each exercise is placed in the phase where it delivers the most value, though several (marked with *) can be adapted across phases.

Empathize Phase

Phase
Exercise
Time
Group
Diff.
Remote
Best For
Origin / Source
Empathize
Empathy Map
30 min
4–8
2/5
Yes
Visualizing what users think, feel, say, do
XPLANE / Gamestorming
Empathize
User Interview Pairs
20 min
6–12
1/5
Yes
First-timers. Immediate empathy practice
Stanford d.school
Empathize
Day-in-the-Life Map
25 min
4–6
2/5
Partial
Service design. Spotting pain points in routines
IDEO HCD Toolkit
Empathize
Persona Creation
30 min
4–8
3/5
Yes
Teams with user data. Building shared user models
Alan Cooper, About Face

Define Phase

Phase
Exercise
Time
Group
Diff.
Remote
Best For
Origin / Source
Define
“How Might We” Statements
20 min
4–12
2/5
Yes
Reframing problems as opportunities
P&G / IDEO
Define
Five Whys *
15 min
2–6
1/5
Yes
Root cause analysis. Cutting through symptoms
Toyota Production System
Define
Dot Voting
10 min
6–20
1/5
Yes
Quick democratic prioritization. Large groups
Gamestorming
Define
Problem Statement Fill-in
15 min
4–8
2/5
Yes
Forcing clarity: “[User] needs [need] because [insight]”
Stanford d.school

Ideate Phase

Phase
Exercise
Time
Group
Diff.
Remote
Best For
Origin / Source
Ideate
Crazy Eights
8 min
4–12
1/5
Partial
Rapid visual ideation. Energy boost after lunch
Google Ventures Sprint
Ideate
Brainwriting 6-3-5
30 min
6
2/5
Yes
Equal participation. 108 ideas in 30 min. Quiet teams
Bernd Rohrbach, 1969
Ideate
SCAMPER
20 min
4–8
3/5
Yes
Iterating on existing concepts. Product improvement
Bob Eberle / Alex Osborn
Ideate
Round Robin Brainstorm
15 min
6–12
1/5
Yes
Preventing dominant voices. Ensuring all contribute
Standard facilitation
Ideate
Note and Vote
10 min
4–20
1/5
Yes
Democratic selection after brainstorm. Quick convergence
Google Ventures Sprint

Prototype Phase

Phase
Exercise
Time
Group
Diff.
Remote
Best For
Origin / Source
Prototype
Paper Prototype
30 min
2–4
2/5
No
Digital products. Sketching screens and flows
Standard UX practice
Prototype
Storyboard
25 min
2–4
3/5
Partial
Service design. Visualizing the full user journey
Disney / UX adapted
Prototype
Role-Play / Act It Out
20 min
4–8
2/5
No
Service experiences. Revealing friction physical mockups miss
IDEO / Improv theater

Test Phase

Phase
Exercise
Time
Group
Diff.
Remote
Best For
Origin / Source
Test
Feedback Capture Grid
15 min
4–12
1/5
Yes
Structured feedback: Likes, Wishes, Questions, Ideas
Stanford d.school
Test
Priority Matrix (2×2)
15 min
4–8
2/5
Yes
Sorting feedback by impact vs. effort. Actionable next steps
Lean / Agile adapted

Prototyping at work is giving form to an idea, allowing us to learn from it, evaluate it against others, and improve upon it.

Tim Brown, Change by Design

Exercises by Difficulty: Quick Reference

If your team has never done design thinking before, start with difficulty 1–2 exercises only. Save level 3+ for teams with at least one prior workshop experience.

Difficulty
Exercises
Who It’s For
1/5
User Interviews, Five Whys, Dot Voting, Crazy Eights, Round Robin, Note and Vote, Feedback Grid
Complete beginners. No DT vocabulary needed. Works on day one.
2/5
Empathy Map, Day-in-the-Life, HMW Statements, Problem Statement, Brainwriting, Paper Prototype, Role-Play, Priority Matrix
Teams with basic familiarity. One prior workshop or a 15-min intro is enough.
3/5
Persona Creation, SCAMPER, Storyboard
Teams with DT experience. Require facilitator guidance and contextual setup.

Remote-Friendly Exercises: What Works Digitally

11 of 18 exercises are fully remote-compatible using tools like Miro, FigJam, or MURAL. Three work partially (lose some effectiveness). Four require physical materials and in-person interaction.

Rating
Exercises
Yes (11)
Empathy Map, User Interviews, HMW, Five Whys, Dot Voting, Problem Statement, Brainwriting 6-3-5, SCAMPER, Round Robin, Note and Vote, Feedback Grid, Priority Matrix
Partial (3)
Day-in-the-Life Map, Crazy Eights (sketching on camera is awkward), Storyboard (needs screen sharing)
No (4)
Persona Creation (benefits from wall-size format), Paper Prototype, Role-Play / Act It Out

What Facilitators Actually Use: A 2026 Survey

In early 2026, an informal poll of 87 workshop facilitators and L&D managers across Alberta and British Columbia asked which exercises they use most frequently and which they’ve dropped:

Finding
Result
Commentary
Most reliable ideation exercise
Crazy Eights
52% of facilitators named it their go-to. Fast, visual, energizing.
Most skipped phase
Empathize
34% admitted cutting empathy exercises under time pressure — the biggest mistake they cited.
Favourite beginner exercise
Five Whys
Universally accessible. No design vocabulary needed. Works in 15 minutes.
Exercise most often dropped after first use
SCAMPER
28% tried it once and switched to simpler methods. Requires too much facilitator explanation.
Best remote exercise
Brainwriting 6-3-5
Works better online than in person — digital passing is faster than physical sheets.
Most underrated exercise
Role-Play
Only 19% use it regularly, but 89% of those rated it “highly effective” for service design.
Top workshop killer
Too much talking
59% said facilitators talking more than 5 min at a stretch is the number one energy killer.

Methodology: Non-scientific convenience sample via LinkedIn groups and email outreach. Respondent pool: primarily Calgary/Edmonton-based facilitators. Not generalizable. Full data available on request.

Three Starter Kits: Exercise Combos by Team Experience

Not sure which exercises to combine? Here are three pre-built combinations based on team experience level:

Phase
Beginner Kit (3 hrs)
Intermediate Kit (6 hrs)
Advanced Kit (2 days)
Empathize
User Interview Pairs
Empathy Map + Day-in-the-Life
Persona Creation + Field Observation
Define
Five Whys
HMW Statements + Dot Voting
Problem Statement + Stakeholder Map
Ideate
Crazy Eights
Brainwriting 6-3-5 + Note and Vote
SCAMPER + Round Robin + Dot Voting
Prototype
— (skip for 3-hr)
Paper Prototype
Storyboard + Role-Play
Test
— (skip for 3-hr)
Feedback Capture Grid
User Testing + Priority Matrix
Total exercises
3
7
10+

There is nothing more frustrating than coming up with the right answer to the wrong question.

Tim Brown, CEO of IDEO

Design Thinking Exercises by the Numbers

  • Brainwriting 6-3-5 generates 108 ideas in 30 minutes — more than any other structured ideation method of comparable duration (Bernd Rohrbach, 1969).
  • The Stanford d.school Wallet Exercise takes 90 minutes and covers empathize, define, and ideate in one session — the most popular introductory activity worldwide.
  • A meta-analysis of 25 studies (Nature, 2024) found design thinking most effective with groups of 30 or fewer (r = 0.436, p < 0.001).
  • Google Ventures’ Design Sprint compresses the 5-phase process into 5 days — one phase per day, Monday through Friday. The book has sold over 1 million copies.
  • 16% of Fortune 500 companies had implemented formal design thinking workshops by 2023 (NIST). The design thinking market reached $9.14 billion in 2025.
  • IDEO’s 1999 Nightline shopping cart challenge — redesigning a cart in 5 days — remains the most-watched design thinking demonstration and is used in university curricula globally.

All of us are smarter than any of us.

Tim Brown, IDEO

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a design thinking workshop?

A design thinking workshop is a facilitated, activity-based session where teams use a structured process (empathize, define, ideate, prototype, test) to solve a specific challenge. Unlike meetings, participants build prototypes, interview users, and test ideas. Sessions run 3–8 hours with 6–12 participants. The exercises in the comparison table above are the building blocks of every workshop.

How do you facilitate a design thinking workshop?

Set time blocks for each phase, explain exercises briefly (less than 3 minutes per instruction), then step back and let participants work. The facilitator manages process, not content. Intervene only to keep time, redirect off-topic discussion, or draw out quiet participants. Use the starter kits above to select exercises matching your team’s experience level.

How do you conduct a design thinking workshop remotely?

Use Miro, FigJam, or MURAL for digital sticky notes. 11 of the 18 exercises above are fully remote-compatible. Break longer workshops into 2-hour blocks across multiple days. Send physical materials (paper, markers) to participants in advance for exercises marked “Partial” or “No” in the remote column.

What are the best design thinking exercises for beginners?

Start with difficulty 1/5 exercises: User Interview Pairs (empathize), Five Whys (define), Crazy Eights (ideate), and Feedback Capture Grid (test). These four cover the full design thinking cycle in under 90 minutes and require zero prior experience. The Beginner Kit in the starter table above uses exactly this combination.


Last updated: November 2026. Exercise ratings reflect facilitator feedback and published methodology documentation. This page is maintained as an independent educational resource.